The logistics sector appears to have great difficulty raising prices. Furthermore, compared to other industries, it has an extremely low success rate when introducing new products and services. These are the results of a recent special analysis of the Global Pricing Study 2014, conducted by the global strategy consulting firm Simon-Kucher & Partners. The results are based on responses from approximately 1,600 managers from the most important industries. According to the results, logistics firms succeed with only 40 per cent of their planned price increases. And almost 80 per cent of the companies are experiencing higher price pressure compared to last year.
Logistics providers say these poor results are due to fierce competition, and the fact that customers have more negotiating power now. As a result, the percentage of logistics companies that only compete on price is twice as high as in other industries. Blame is quickly placed on the competitors, although the inability to raise prices is generally self-inflicted, says Dr. Philipp Biermann, Partner at Simon-Kucher: “Logistics firms often lack confidence and negotiation tactics. They are frequently at the mercy of their customers’ professional purchasing departments. Recognizing the value of one’s services, developing a negotiation strategy and translating this into an implementable price, this is what logistics managers must get this into their heads!”
Price pressure and new product flops
The combination of external pressure and low confidence in their own performance has caused almost two-thirds of the respondents, as they report, to suffer from price wars. All of them, however, say that it was the competition, not themselves, who started it. “The phenomenon that companies make concessions to their customers in the heat of the moment that they actually cannot justify is very widespread in the logistics industry. In the process, they often don’t see the signals that their price-cutting give to the competition. They don’t grasp that these ‘isolated cases’ ultimately have a negative impact on the market price level,” explains Kornelia Reifenberg, Senior Director at Simon-Kucher.
In addition, when it comes to launching new products and services, the logistics industry has also been struggling: Only 18 per cent of all new products achieve their profit targets, which is the lowest rate that has ever been recorded (considering that in all industries it’s 28 per cent). And 35 per cent of logistics companies haven’t even been able to reach the anticipated profit targets for any of their new products (compared to the overall percentage of 24 per cent), although these new products and services could well be used to shift the focus of negotiations away from price toward value, Reifenberg says.
Know your products, communicate customer value.
How can logistics providers successfully compete against low-priced competitors, implement price increases on the market and establish new products? Industry expert Biermann urges them to carefully differentiate customers and services: “One-size-fits-all products are doomed to failure.”
It would be better, he says, to proactively offer several service options to make customers recognize the values of the different offerings: “Cheap services are possible, but they require a narrower service breadth — for example when it comes to flexibility, payment terms or goodwill agreements. If customers want these premium services, then they should also pay for them.” This is how to turn a one-size-fits-all commodity into one that is tailor-made to meet a customer’s specific needs. “It’s a give and take situation”, says Biermann. “By all means, customers should have the freedom to choose.” And they should get the opportunity to avoid effective price increases, e.g. by accepting alternative loading/delivery times or larger shipment volumes.
Approximately 1,600 participants, of which 39 per cent are C-levels, from companies of all industries and over 40 countries across Asia-Pacific, the Americas and Europe, took part in 2014 in an online study conducted by Simon-Kucher, and published as Global Pricing Study 2014. For the special analysis the consultancy recently investigated the answers of respondents from the logistics sector concerning their business environment, pricing practices and pricing performance. The study takes place every two years in collaboration with the independent Professional Pricing Society (PPS).